Germany contemplates suspending budget brake amid economic woes
The economic slowdown and decline in tax revenues are prompting part of the German government to discuss suspending the controversial budget brake. Negotiations on the 2025 budget are dragging on, according to the latest weekly edition from the Polish Economic Institute.
Germany is considering easing its restrictive budget policy due to increasingly worse economic data. As the Polish Economic Institute reported, the economic downturn in Germany translates to lower-than-expected budget revenues. Estimates published in May 2024 indicate that federal revenues will be €3.7 billion (approximately CAD 5.3 billion) lower this year than projected and an average of €8 billion (about CAD 11.5 billion) lower in subsequent years. The necessity to abide by strict debt limits is forcing Berlin to look for savings, which is met with opposition from parts of the government, according to Sebastian Sajnóg's article.
Germany has had enough of restrictions
The prevailing budget brake in Germany, intended to guarantee the stability of public finances, limits the ability to incur new debts. According to this rule, the structural deficit at the federal level cannot exceed 0.35 percent of GDP. Since 2020, the states must maintain balanced fiscal policies, precluding increasing debt except in extraordinary situations.
Weak economic performance further narrows the maneuvering room. 2023, the German GDP shrank by 0.3 percent, and the European Commission forecasts only symbolic growth of 0.1 percent this year. This necessitates even tighter deficit restraints compared to last year. Estimates project that in 2025, expenditures will be about €25 billion (approximately CAD 36 billion) lower than in 2024.
The new budget project forces the search for savings. Adherence to constitutional fiscal policy principles has led to cuts in almost all ministries and establishing upper spending limits. These measures, however, face criticism from some ministers, mainly associated with the SPD and the Greens. According to the PIE report, the Ministries of the Interior, Labour, Defence, and Development Cooperation express skepticism about austerity.
As noted by the author, Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock from the Green Party is demanding a budget of around €7 billion (around CAD 10 billion), arguing that otherwise, humanitarian aid for conflict regions such as the Middle East or Ukraine would have to be cut by about half.
Defence Minister Boris Pistorius is also against the cuts, asserting that the country's defence capabilities are just as crucial as reducing debt. The Interior Ministry takes a similar stance.
Germany fears a downturn
Discrepancies in the approach to savings are dragging on budget negotiations. The original deadline for adopting the 2025 budget project expires on July 3, but it is already known that it will not be met. Final decisions are expected later, although politicians declare an agreement should be reached in July.
In light of the economic slowdown, the discussion on the justification of the stringent budget brake is returning. While it aims to maintain the stability of public finances, it is often criticized for limiting the possibility of conducting counter-cyclical fiscal policy. According to opponents, rigid debt limits can deepen and prolong periods of weaker economic conditions, preventing an adequate response to changing economic conditions, according to the PIE report.
According to Bloomberg, one of the options being considered is to create an additional budget for the coming year, assuming an increase in loans of €11 billion (approximately CAD 16 billion). This solution would compensate for the loss of tax revenues and support the economy through increased public spending.
